Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Baseball

D3 Baseball Players Who Made it to Major League Baseball

Talent can emerge from unexpected places. It isn’t always confined to the powerhouse programs you see on ESPN.

Joe Nathan, Eric Kratz, and more Division 3 baseball alumni who made it to MLB (Major League Baseball)
Credit-MLB/AP/Joker Mag

Many kids dream of becoming a professional baseball player. Donning the uniform of their favorite team. Running out under the lights to thousands of roaring fans. Hitting a walk-off home run in Game 7 of the World Series.

But, you need to beat long odds to get there.

According to Casino.org, only 5.8% of high school seniors ever play for an NCAA baseball program. And just 0.5% of those college seniors get drafted by an MLB team. Even then, per Baseball America, only 17.6% of players drafted make it all the way to the big leagues.

And yet, talent can emerge from unexpected places. It isn’t always confined to the powerhouse programs you see on ESPN. Future big leaguers can be found at every level of college baseball.

Here is a breakdown of Division 3 players who made it to Major League Baseball – now and throughout history.

Active MLB Players Who Played D3 Baseball

Mason Miller – RHP, Waynesburg University

A quote from MLB pitcher Mason Miller that reads: "Baseball is baseball is still baseball at any level. The bases are still 90 feet apart and the field is the same. Some things don’t change."

Mason Miller played four seasons at Division III Waynesburg University – a private college south of Pittsburgh with less than 2,000 students.

The 6’5″ right-hander was only throwing in the low-80s when he finished his sophomore season with a 7.16 ERA.

“To that point, it really wasn’t a dream to play past college,” Miller told The San Francisco Chronicle. “It was more just something I enjoyed…During my junior year is when baseball became semi-realistic again.”

The catalyst to his meteoric rise was finding out he had Type 1 diabetes at 20 years old. Not only did Miller adjust his life to manage the disease, but he started putting on weight and throwing harder.

By his junior season, Miller was pumping low 90s and posted a 1.86 ERA alongside 97 strikeouts. Then, with an extra year of eligibility due to the pandemic, he postponed entering the workforce and transferred to Division I Gardner-Webb University.

The Oakland A’s selected Mason Miller in the third round of the 2021 MLB Draft, and he made his big league debut two years later.

You can read more about Miller’s improbable journey in our full profile here.

Josh Fleming – LHP, Webster University

Quote from MLB pitcher Josh Fleming: "Going into my senior year [of high school] – I was 5'8", 130-140 pounds."

“I grew up very undersized, very small,” Fleming remembers. “In high school – going into my senior year – I was 5’8″, 130, 140 pounds.”

Needless to say, the left-hander didn’t receive much recruiting attention. The only program that believed in him was D3 Webster University in Missouri.

Fleming made a big jump as a freshman for the Gorloks, hitting 90mph on the radar gun for the first time in his life. As he improved, scouts started showing up to every game he pitched.

Ultimately, the Rays took him in the 5th round of the 2017 draft, and the lefty made his MLB debut just four years later.

RELATED: The Biggest Misconceptions About D3 Baseball (According to College Coaches)

Colin Selby – RHP, Randolph-Macon College

Colin Selby went from unknown Division 3 prospect to MLB pitcher

Holding out for a big SEC school, Colin Selby initially ignored the D3 coaches who contacted him. That is, until he was coming to the end of his high school career.

“I was actually kind of a stubborn kid going into it,” Selby told Pittsburgh Baseball Now.

“And then once the high school period started coming to an end and realizing I wasn’t really getting the calls that I wanted to, started reaching out to some of the D-III teams that reached out to me that I kind of just ignored in the past. And thankfully, they stuck with me.”

After Selby posted a 2.60 ERA and 11.7 K/9 in 2018, the Pirates drafted him in the 16th round. He worked his way through the minor league ranks for 6 years before Pittsburgh called him up to the big leagues in August of 2023.

Collin McHugh – RHP, Berry College

After graduating from high school, Collin McHugh continued his baseball career at Division III Berry College in Georgia.

In three seasons, he posted a 4.29 ERA across 171.1 innings. The Mets drafted him in the 18th round of the 2008 season, and after working his way up the rungs of the minors, McHugh became the first player from Berry to play in an MLB game.

He grew up idolizing Atlanta Braves legends like Greg Maddux and Tom Glavine. Now, with a World Series ring on his finger, he’s wearing the uniform of his hometown team. For real this time.

Tim Locastro – OF, Ithaca College

Locastro’s high school coach, an alumnus of Ithaca’s baseball program, paved the way for Tim to play for his alma mater. There, the speedster weighed in at a mere 164 pounds as a college freshman. But he put in serious work for scouts to take notice.

“It was a grind all the way up, but you just gotta keep fightin’,” Locastro said on MLB Network’s Hot Stove.

Selected in the 13th round in 2013, the lightning-fast outfielder set an impressive record as an MLB rookie – stealing 29 straight bases to start his career.

Caleb Boushley – RHP, University of Wisconsin–La Crosse

Drafted in the 33rd round by the San Diego Padres in 2017, Caleb Boushley stayed in their organization for four years.

After posting a 39-31 record and 4.23 ERA in his minor league career, the Wisconsin native made his major league debut with his hometown Milwaukee Brewers in September of 2023.

The righty took an unconventional route, playing club baseball for two years at University of Wisconsin-Fox Valley while deciding what to study. Then he transferred to Wisconsin-La Crosse, where he impressed scouts with two All-American seasons.

He struck out 5 batters across 2 and 1/3 innings of work in his MLB debut, proving that D3 guys can do it too!

“You try to play out how it’s going to go in your head, and then when you’re in the moment, just take it a pitch at a time,” Boushley told MLB.com. “It’s better than I dreamed.”

Kevin Herget – RHP, Kean University

Herget is a 5’10” right-hander out of Kean University – a decorated D3 program in Union, New Jersey.

He spent 9 years grinding through the ranks of the minor leagues, making it all the way to Triple-A in 2016, but never taking the final step.

Then, in August of 2022, the former 39th-round pick finally got the call to make his major league debut at the age of 31.

Casey Lawrence – RHP, Albright College

After going undrafted out of a small-town high school in Pennsylvania, the right-hander attended Division III Albright College in his hometown state. Despite setting the school’s strikeout record in his 4-year career there, he went undrafted again in 2010.

Lawrence slowly worked his way up the minors, eventually cracking the Blue Jays’ big league roster in 2017.

“You know technically, I’m not even really supposed to be here right now,” he told the Toronto Sun in 2011. “So…might as well make the most of it.”

Stephen Ridings – RHP, Haverford College

At 6’8″, Stephen Ridings was an imposing presence at Division 3 Haverford College. He impressed pro scouts his junior season, fanning 87 Centennial Conference hitters in 65.1 innings.

The Cubs took him in the 8th round in 2016, where Ridings spent several years before being shipped to Kansas City.

After posting a 5.91 ERA in rookie ball, the Royals released him. While some thought his playing days were over, Ridings refused to quit – reviving his career and getting a chance in the big leagues with the New York Yankees.

Former Major Leaguers Who Played at the Division 3 Level

Billy Wagner – LHP, Ferrum College

Billy Wagner was only 5'5" and 135 pounds as a senior in high school.

Billy Wagner’s underdog story is second-to-none.

He was 5-years-old when his parents divorced, and spent his childhood living with various family members. According to Sports Illustrated, his family relied on food stamps to keep everyone fed.

A natural-born righty, Wagner taught himself to throw left-handed after breaking his arm twice as a kid.

He was only 5’5″ and 135 pounds as a senior in high school, causing many college programs to look past him.

After following his cousin to Division 3 Ferrum College in Virginia, Wagner set NCAA records before beginning a long major league career. A 7-time All-Star, Billy Wagner will go down as one of the best closers in baseball history.

RELATED: D3 Football Players in the NFL – Now & Through History

Joe Nathan – RHP, Stony Brook University

Despite being a three-sport athlete in high school, Joe Nathan received minimal interest from Division III schools. He landed at Stony Brook – a D3 program at the time – partly because of a connection his high school coach had there.

After moving from shortstop to the mound, Nathan’s future as a pitcher was solidified. The San Francisco Giants drafted him 159th overall, and he went on to become a 6-time All-Star closer with the Minnesota Twins.

“Stony Brook was the perfect fit because it allowed me to play and grow,” Nathan told the Times Herald-Record. “I’m just glad I got stronger and (San Francisco) was patient through all of my trials and tribulations.”

In 2008, the college named its new baseball stadium Joe Nathan Field.

Erik Kratz – C, Eastern Mennonite University

Erik Kratz caught every at-bat of every game he played for Eastern Mennonite, a small liberal arts college in Harrisonburg, Virginia. He won the conference’s Player of the Year honors twice and broke the NCAA Division III record for doubles in a career.

The Blue Jays selected him 866th overall, and Kratz fought an uphill battle, spending six years rising through the ranks of the minors. After finally making the major league roster at age 30, he stuck around, playing for nine different teams across 11 MLB seasons.

Persistence pays off!

Jordan Zimmermann – RHP, University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point

In four years of varsity baseball, Zimmermann moved around the diamond – splitting time as a catcher, starting pitcher, and closer. He continued his career at UW-Stevens Point – where, as a quiet sophomore pitcher, he led his team to the D3 College World Series.

Zimmermann did it again the following season, which impressed the Washington Nationals enough to grab him in the second round – making him one of the highest Division III selections of the past 20 years.

Now, the right-hander has accomplished more than anyone expected: two All-Star selections, a no-hitter, a National League wins title, and – best of all – his college baseball field named after him.

More notable D3 alumni:

  • Tony Womack – MIF, Guilford College
  • J. P. Feyereisen – RHP, University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point
  • Chris Coste – C, Concordia College
  • Terry Mulholland – LHP, Marietta College
  • Eric Owens – OF, Ferrum College
  • Rusty Kuntz – OF, California State University, Stanislaus
  • Gary Varsho – OF, University of Wisconsin–Oshkosh
  • Jarrod Washburn – LHP, University of Wisconsin–Oshkosh
  • Nelson Figueroa – RHP, Brandeis University
  • Chris Denorfia – OF, Wheaton College
  • Anthony Recker – C, Alvernia College
  • Chris Heisey – OF, Messiah University
  • Charlie Furbush – LHP, Saint Joseph’s College of Maine
  • Bruce Maxwell – C, Birmingham–Southern College
  • Matt DeSalvo – RHP, Marietta College
  • Kent Tekulve – RHP, Marietta College
  • Dan Pasqua – 1B/OF, William Paterson University
Recommended
ProductiveRecruit: The All-in-One College Sports Recruiting Platform

Ready to be a college athlete? Take complete control of your recruiting process and find the perfect fit with ProductiveRecruit – an all-in-one platform that allows you to connect with any college coach in the country.

Pros:
  • Joker Mag readers get 15% off their first year!
  • Connect with 80,000+ coaches across 22 sports
  • Track which coaches are opening your emails
Joker Mag is reader-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Check out the rest of our small college-to-pro series:

Written By

Division III baseball alum (McDaniel College) and founder of Joker Mag. Sharing underdog stories to inspire the next generation.

Related

Football

This undrafted special teamer almost quit football before becoming a Pro Bowl NFL safety. All thanks to one pivotal conversion.

Football

The 243rd overall pick went from slingin' burgers to hoisting the Lombardi Trophy.

Interviews

Once told he'd be raised in a wheelchair, this Texas high schooler is on a mission to "Prove Them All Wrong"

Football

He tackled the wrong guy in his first college practice. Four years later, he became the school's all-time sack leader.