There’s nothing quite as sweet as seeing an underdog win a sports contest. David vs. Goliath. The We Believe Warriors vs. the Dallas Mavericks. Wall Street Bets vs. Melvin Capital.
Well, maybe one thing – winning money by betting on an underdog. All conventional wisdom working against you. The oddsmakers laughing in your face. And in the end – you coming out on top.
So here’s an homage to those lucky souls that overcame the odds, whether it was because of freak luck or a herculean effort from an underdog.
These are the biggest Vegas odds upsets in sports history.
1.) Leicester City Win the English Premier League (+500,000)
The English Premier League is one of those leagues where the cream tends to rise to the top. Since 2010, only 5 teams have won the league: Manchester United, Manchester City, Chelsea, and Liverpool – and in 2015, Leicester City.
Leicester City was sitting at +500,000 to win the EPL at the beginning of the season. This wasn’t improbable, it was nearly impossible. And yet, they pulled it off.
And someone was able to turn £100 into £200,000 by laying on them to win. It’s hard to overstate this level of upset.
2.) Miracle on Ice at the 1980 Winter Olympics (+100,000)
The “Miracle on Ice” was an ice hockey game during the 1980 Winter Olympics in Lake Placid, New York. It was played between the hosting United States and the Soviet Union on February 22, 1980, during the medal round of the men’s hockey tournament.
It’s tough to explain how much of a dog the U.S. team was in this one. This was literally a 1,000 to 1 shot. A $100 wager on the team would have yielded a total return of $100,000.
In the four Olympics following their 1960 bronze-medal finish at Squaw Valley, Soviet teams had gone 27–1–1 (wins-losses-ties) and outscored their opponents 175–44.
Just a few days before the Olympics in Lake Placid, the United States team was thumped by the Soviets 10-3. Hence the line. I don’t even think Herb Brooks would have put money on the U.S. team.
During the game, the U.S. team was down 2-3 going into the third period, and scored two late goals to stun the Soviet team by winning 4-3.
As an aside, this made Al Michaels’ career, when he declared: “Do you believe in miracles? YES!“
3.) 2011 St. Louis Cardinals Win the World Series (+99,900)
In 2011, the St. Louis Cardinals were not in pole position to make a run at the World Series. In fact, they were 4 ½ games behind the Atlanta Braves for the National League Wild Card spot, with only 15 games left in the regular season.
Accordingly, Las Vegas sportsbooks had them listed at 999 to 1 to win the World Series.
But, as they tend to do from time to time in sports, the unexpected happened. The Cardinals put up an 11-4 record in their final 15 games, and the Braves wilted.
St. Louis made it all the way to the World Series where they toppled the Texas Rangers to become WS champions, and made the lucky bettors who laid on them a nice chunk of change.
4.) 1999 St. Louis Rams Win Super Bowl (+30,000)
This was the year the “Greatest Show on Turf” took the field for the St. Louis Rams. But before they became the Greatest Show, they were the biggest joke. The Rams teams of the late ‘90s were horrific.
To make matters worse, the Rams’ free-agent QB signing, Trent Green, suffered a season-ending injury before Week 1. Remember who took over? That’s right, Kurt Warner, an unknown grocery bagger from Cedar Falls, Iowa.
The rest, as they like to say, is history. Marshall Faulk, Kurt Warner, Isaac Bruce and Tory Holt tore up opposing defenses. And cemented their legacy as the biggest pre-season longshot winners in Super Bowl history at 300 to 1.
5.) 2004: Boston Red Sox Win World Series (+12,000)
The Boston Red Sox were 120 to 1 underdogs to win the World Series in 2004. It’s surprising they weren’t further dogs considering the “Curse of the Bambino”.
But, the curse was lifted as the Red Sox toppled the St. Louis Cardinals in the World Series. The Red Sox were actually down 3-0 to the New York Yankees in the American League Championship Series leading up to the World Series.
But they were able to win 4 straight games to overcome their deficit, becoming the only team in the Major League Baseball to do so in the playoffs.
6.) 2009 Kentucky Derby Winner Mine That Bird (+5,000)
Mine That Bird was a 50 to 1 dog in the 2009 Kentucky Derby. His bloodline was nothing to write home about. But the horse brought home the bacon when it counted, amassing over $2.2M in career earnings.
The oddsmakers hadn’t caught on to that prior to the 2009 Kentucky Derby. You can even hear the announcer saying that “Well behind the rest of them, is Mine That Bird”.
We highly recommend you listen to the call. It’s hilarious when the announcer stumbles over himself down the backstretch. “Now towards the inside coming on through, that is, uh…Mine That Bird now who is coming on to take the lead!”
Mine That Bird won by 7-lengths.
7.) Buster Douglas KOs Mike Tyson (+4200)
Looking over this line of +4200, it’s shocking that it wasn’t more slanted. This was during the era of Mike Tyson, a fighter that struck fear into any would-be challengers.
Coming into this fight, Tyson was 37-0 with 33 knockouts. He didn’t just win, he won early and with ferocity.
Buster Douglas, in contrast, was an undecorated unknown. He had nearly 7 years of age and 4 more losses on Tyson. But, as they say, everyone has a puncher’s chance if they hop in the ring. No man is immortal.
Unlike most of Tyson’s other fights, this one went all the way to the 10th round. Tyson dropped Douglas in the 8th round, knocking him down with a vicious uppercut. Douglas stumbled to his feet at the 9 count.
And he kept coming, throwing a right hook that hobbled Tyson. Douglas then threw a series of jabs and hooks that put Tyson on his back.
The rest is history. Tyson’s run of dominance never quite continued. Douglas, on the other hand, lost his next fight to Evander Holyfield and faded into obscurity.
8.) 2007 Stanford vs. USC (No Moneyline – Spread 41 points)
The Stanford Cardinal entered this college football game as 41 point underdogs to the USC Trojans.
To give you an idea of how big of an upset this was: most sportsbooks don’t bother posting moneylines for games with such large point spreads, and this game was no exception.
This was at the height of the Pete Carroll – Jim Harbaugh rivalry that eventually spilled over into the NFL.
Stanford was able to win in the final minute 24-23 on a go ahead touchdown pass to Mark Bradford. The QB, Tavita Pritchard, was making his first career start.
If that isn’t inspiring, we don’t know what is.
9.) No 16 UMBC vs. No. 1 Virginia (+2,000)
The Retrievers defeated the Cavaliers 74–54, becoming the first No. 16 seed to defeat a No. 1 seed in the NCAA Division I Men’s Basketball Tournament.
Virginia came into the tournament with a regular season record of 31–2. The UMBC team completed the regular season with a 24–10 record.
UMBC’s Jairus Lyles, who scored 28 points while battling through cramps late in the second half, was named the game’s Most Valuable Player.
March Madness indeed.
10.) 2016 Cleveland Cavaliers Win NBA Title (+1,100)
This stands as the only time in NBA history that a team has come back from 3-1 in the championship series. The Cavaliers won their first championship in franchise history and brought the first pro sports title to Cleveland in 52 years.
Interestingly enough, the Warriors pulled off their own comeback from down 1-3 in the Conference Finals vs. the Oklahoma City Thunder. It is one of three 3-1 comebacks to be achieved in the Conference Finals of the playoffs.
Bettor Secrets is a newsletter focused on sports betting news, tips, and tricks from sharps you can’t get anywhere else. Track the key lines and opportunities to max your EV.
Win more sports betting in just 5 minutes. Get sports betting insights and entertainment all in one. Sign up now and start betting with an edge: https://bettorsecrets.com.
Want More Underdog Stories?
Get a bite-sized rundown of the best underdog stories in sports – handpicked from across the web & delivered to your inbox every Tuesday.Join 2,055+ Weekly Readers